DisMemberHansard: Cheat Mode Activated← Search Parliament
Classic DisMember·Historic Parliament

DisMember writes

Bevin, handed dictatorial powers over British labour, explains that the secret of wartime output is not using them — and that the real slackers in the munitions economy are the managements.


The speech

Ernest BevinLab

2 April 1941 · Minister of Labour and National Service · House of Commons

The key quote

“Every decent manager in this country knows that if you overdo the ordering business, you get a reaction and disaster; that is not the way to get output.”

Defending his conduct of wartime labour supply, Bevin refuses the demand to stop persuading and start ordering: compulsion overdone destroys output. The real bottleneck, he shows from that day's casework — fifty women sacked in a fortnight, sixty night workers sent home for want of material — is management, and he will go on intervening until the conditions for using labour actually exist.

Read in Hansard →

Historical context

April 1941, with the Blitz still falling and Britain's war economy in its great expansion. Churchill had brought Bevin — general secretary of the Transport and General Workers' Union, never before in Parliament — straight into the Cabinet in May 1940 and given him near-total power over the working population; the Essential Work Orders he speaks of here made him, by common consent, the most powerful home-front minister of the war. The speech displays exactly why the arrangement worked: a trade unionist's instinct that consent outproduces compulsion, wielded with statutory powers Hitler's economy never matched in practice. The scolding of management — delivered by the man the Tory press had expected to be labour's shop steward in government — inverted every expectation, and production vindicated him. His measures put more women into industry than any country outside Russia, and the machinery of consultation he built ran British industrial relations for a generation. The man himself went on to the Foreign Office in 1945 and the co-authorship of NATO — much of it run on the credit banked in years of afternoons like this one.

DisMember scores

Rhetorical brilliance6/10
Prescience6/10
Emotional weight6/10
Aggression6/10
Irony6/10
Humbug2/10

Topics

wartime labour supplywomen in industrywar productionmanagement failuresdrop forgingsdock outputBirmingham munitionswelfare in factoriesEssential Work Orderspersuasion versus compulsionhome front 1941
Share on BlueskyShare on X

Explore Parliament yourself

Search sixteen years of Commons debate

Find the memorable moments, not just the keywords. Semantic search across 325,000+ enriched contributions.

Search Parliament →

Historical context and scoring written by AI (Gemini). The key quote is verbatim from Hansard. Verify against source before publishing.